Saints scholars and schizophrenics essay

While women also imbibe during the long winters, this habit is often hidden in socially acceptable 'cures' for melancholia. Tightly knit communities would tend to be more cooperative during the planting and harvesting seasons and better able to weather natural and manmade disasters. Her original intention was to investigate the sexual lives of remote Irish villagers using the interpretive method, but when she stumbled upon statistics showing a shocking number of villagers being diagnosed with schizophrenia she could not resist tackling that topic.

The ability to conform to social norms within conservative rural Irish communities, even if it means second class citizenship, is therefore protective against mental illness as defined by the community.

Scheper-Hughes herself remarked that many felt betrayed by her book, and that they initially had no idea what she would publish Scheper-Hughes However, it is important to obtain and disclose such secrets under clear ethical guidelines.

She has characterized the efforts of patients waiting for an organ transplant to save their lives through purchasing a replacement organ from a volunteer as just "a new form of commodity fetishism.

She informed the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which led to arrests several years later. These men and women were living a life of celibacy on a farm equivalent to the lifestyle chosen by priests, thus the word "Saints" in the title.

Though her fieldwork led to her eventual expulsion from Ballybran and continues to undergo scrutiny by the anthropological community, it is nevertheless an important case study in the necessity of strict ethical Saints scholars and schizophrenics essay when working in the field.

To avoid the loss of manpower needed for running farms, marriage was often arranged between households within the community.

Mental Illness in Rural Ireland Academic Essay

The ability to conform to social norms within conservative rural Irish communities, even if it means second class citizenship, is therefore protective against mental illness as defined by the community. Schizophrenia was therefore being used as a catch-all diagnosis for what she called "transient psychosis" due to being conferred second class citizenship p.

Based on health statistics for developed nations, Ireland had the highest male celibacy and psychiatric hospitalization rates by a wide margin p. Her work in Latin America, South AfricaIrelandand Eastern Europe traces the insidious invisibility of everyday violence, which often makes the vulnerable and exploited into their own wardens and executioners.

Nancy Scheper-Hughes

By comparison, the average stay length for married individuals is less than a month. It is true that obtaining proper informed consent from informants means that not all information will be available to the ethnographer; however, this does not necessarily mean that good ethnographic work cannot be accomplished.

Schepper-Hughes' 'Saints' in her ethnographyhowever, discusses the few rebels who escape institutionalization. Clearly some action had been taken to reverse what Scheper-Hughes had concluded was one of the primary causes for schizophrenia; that of parental disinterest in their children One thing that can be said about the work of Scheper-Hughes is that she was committed to pinpointing the social causes of schizophrenia in rural Ireland, which ultimately pointed fingers not at the villagers themselves but at the economic and social hardships that prompted them to act out a certain amount of psychological violence on their children Scheper-Hughes Selected Writings of Franco Basaglia.

She supported her argument by pointing out that the demographic statistics had been thoroughly corrupted by well-intentioned efforts to mask the underlying societal problems eating away at a way of life ill-adapted to modern times.

The former deals strictly with an individual, whereas the latter deals with truths about structural violence which are embedded within society at large and are not necessarily apparent from the inside. For example, compared to British citizens the Irish were times more likely to be hospitalized for alcoholism Schepper-Hughes,p.

The life lived by those who do conform to a community's expectations is grim by anyone's standards. Whole identities could be kept secret by not publishing revealing facts about an individual which are not strictly necessary to the collection or presentation of data.

She has worked as an activist and with social movements in Brazil in defense of rural workers, against death squads, and for the rights of street children in the United States as a civil rights worker and as a Catholic Worker [2] for the homeless mentally ill, against nuclear weapons research at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory [ citation needed ] and internationally in defense of the rights of those who sell their kidneys.

For this reason, suicide rates are also believed by both the authorities and the medical profession to be increasing, as young Irish men and women facing a life of celibacy and servitude no longer view suicide as the worst choice they could make.

Multivocality is certainly important, but if direct quotes, elaborate descriptions and background information are kept to a minimum it would serve the double purpose of concealing identity without fictionalizing it; therefore, the failure of Scheper-Hughes to keep identities in tact while also preserving the integrity of information provided within the strictest confidence serves as a lesson to all anthropologists as to the necessity of full and proper informed consent.

In a lecture, she is reported as identifying two motivations of Israeli traffickers as "greed" and "Revenge, restitution—reparation for the Holocaust. As Schrag asserts, this is simply the best way to treat them as humans and not repositories of knowledge Books[ edit ] a Commodifying Bodies.

As such, they are tolerated and allowed to remain within the community. In a real way, these individuals have carved out a life free of servitude and institutionalization, and as long as they maintain their eccentric ways they are free to live their lives accordingly.

Schepper-Hughes concluded that regardless of their fate, whether forced to go abroad or stay home to serve aging parents, these youth were destined to endure a life without any chance to experience fulfillment in marriage, career, and society. The fires of discontent were further exacerbated as these young and intelligent men and women watched as a select few were chosen to emigrate to what was perceived to be a better future.

Her findings there led her to publish Saints, Scholars and Schizophrenics: Such labels can have a significant impact on the prevalence rates for mental diagnoses and institutionalization.

The world owes it to us. While the social constraints that rural Irish communities imposed on their residents may seem unfair and even represent a form of violence, most local customs are rooted in a pragmatic solution to social problems Schepper-Hughes, Journal of Psychohistory 18 4:.

Nancy Scheper-Hughes and the Question of Ethical Fieldwork

Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics - Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics is the ethnographic study of a small town of An Cloch'an on the Dingle Peninsula in Ireland. Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics: Mental Illness in Rural elonghornsales.com Scheper-Hughes 28 November Anthropology Scheper-Hughes, Nancy Saints, Scholars and Schizophrenics: University of California Press “It is generally accepted that schizophrenia is a condition in which the person alters his representation of reality in order to escape or withdraw from seemingly.

Saints, Scholars and Schizophrenics: Mental Illness in Rural Ireland

Her findings there led her to publish Saints, Scholars and Schizophrenics: Mental Illness in Rural Ireland inin which she attempted to explain the social causes of Ireland’s surprisingly high rates of schizophrenia (Scheper-Hughes ). Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics exist at the nexus of anthropology, psychology, and philosophy” ( Gina Zavota).

Nancy Scheper-Hughes and her in-depth look into the culture of western rural Ireland was detailed, in both her personal experience, but also supported by a vast amount of outside research and help of the medical community.

The trustworthiness of Irish suicide rates has increased since Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics was first published according to Schepper-Hughes () and they reveal a 40% increase in assigning undetermined deaths to suicide. Saints, Scholars, and Schizophrenics exist at the nexus of anthropology, psychology, and philosophy” ( Gina Zavota).

Nancy Scheper-Hughes and her in-depth look into the culture of western rural Ireland was detailed, in both her personal experience, but also supported by a vast amount of outside research and help of the medical community.

Saints scholars and schizophrenics essay
Rated 5/5 based on 70 review
Nancy Scheper-Hughes - Wikipedia